[Field-Homework 3] Disappearing City

 

Theme:

Hong Kong government strives to reconstruct old areas. Tai Hang Sai Estate, is one of them. This place is chosen by me because it is actually a private house estate. It is the only form now in Hong Kong. If it disappears too, there is no such an estate in Hong Kong.

These old areas are going to be disappeared soon due to the urban demand and their aging. However, these are actually places for many people to have memories with. As their daily lives must happen here. Therefore, this video essay is going to discuss how the disappearance of this place affects others by focusing on the elements of the corridor.

In the video, the elements of corridor show the history of those buildings. According to a video, the appearance of Tai Hang Sai Estate is because of a fire in 1952. So Tai Hang Sai Estate has been appeared for almost 70 years. The exposed circuit box, different colored doors, vintage words and numbers printed etc. has also revealed the age of it. People easily omitted the place they are usually by, i.e. corridor. It is usually a long pathway from one place to another. So it is actually a minor space for most of people. Nevertheless, its vanishing may lead to the vanishing of people’s childhood.

Will the disappearance of the place also causes disappearance of memories? This is a question without an  answer. But according to the news, some elders are worried about they cannot handle because they are already too old. At the last of the video, it is mentioned that there is a hope for us to stay positive.

Not only the memories of the residents there, the Tai Hang Say Estates also let people witness the differences of Hong Kong between 1950s and nowadays. Let them to know more about the old architectures of Hong Kong and how the city changes.

 

Methods/Production:

When I first saw the topic, I immediately thought of Tai Hang Tai Estate. As I have lived near it for 10 years and I know how special it is. But I know personal experience experiences are not enough, so I did some research online and watched some videos. Also, I also take reference from some photographic skills and tried to learn them some.

The photographic skill used is mainly close-up. It can help the audience to focus on the subject without any other disturbances. The setting of the movie is mainly to show the normal atmosphere of the Tai Hang Tai Estate, for example, the movement of residents and the lighting.

Diegetic sound is mainly my narration and the natural sounds. To give a theme and show the real life situation to the viewers. Pending photographic skill is also used. It aims to let the audience to feel like they are also walking through the corridors. As the corridors are long, better let them them have a full view.

Several site visiting is also conducted. It is to feel the atmosphere and the observe the people’s movements more specifically. It also allows me to draft my theme more clearly. During my visiting, I think the old environment and the slightly dark environment still impress me a lot, like before. It feels like there would be nowhere else can be this vibe. I also observed that there are a lot of elders which matches the news I have searched before. I then realize that it is due to its history background.

 

Reflection:

Despite of the research and the visiting, the emphasis of corridor regarding to the theme is not strong enough. Since mentioning the disappearance of the whole estate is hard to reduce to only corridor. However, the video does only take elements of corridors. It is to compensate the low emphasis of corridor.

Moreover, the theme of the topic had been changed a few times due to the restriction of the site, i.e. corridor. Since the whole Tai Hang Tai Estate is so large. And I hope to include more elements in the video. Also, I want to emphasize how the environment will disappear soon and tell people to treasure the place they are in everyday, that may seem to be so ordinary. The changes cause few inconvenience and messiness.

 

(712 words)
Hung Shuk Ki 3035840291

Bibliography:

A&M Diary. (2021, Jan 17).〈好遊〉將會在地圖消失 石硤尾大坑西邨. Now News. https://news.now.com/home/life/player?newsId=420584 

Abel. (n.d.) 有片 | 大坑西邨重建安置無期 居民嘆「臨老唔過得世」. Orange News. https://www.orangenews.hk/community/1128381/有片-%7C-大坑西邨重建安置無期%E3%80%80居民嘆「臨老唔過得世」.jhtml 

Hayvlogger. (2022, Apr 6). Tai Hang Sai Estate || 快要重建的大坑西邨. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAKZjJj-_V0  

Hong Kong D. (n.d.). 【石硤尾大坑西新邨】過半世紀老屋邨,定格在上世紀香港的感覺,重建在即,僅餘五老店. Retrieved May 13, 2022, from https://www.hongkongd.com/shek-kip-mei/63813/石硤尾大坑西新邨/ 

HKET. (2021, Apr 17). 石硤尾建築散步 時光定格大坑西邨https://paper.hket.com/article/2934175/石硤尾建築散步%20時光定格大坑西邨 

March Explorer. (2021, Dec 3). 重建前大坑西邨(大坑西新邨)Tai Hang Sai Estate, mhp1914, Nov 2021. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uG54hjXTpkE 

Macroecon. (2020, Dec 8)〈宏觀科技#TECH〉EP_7c: 香港唯一私營廉租屋邨-大坑西邨/ 政府計劃重建/ 平民屋宇/ 安置當年清拆計劃影響的居民 20201208c. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-GIAICFeEM 

MP Weekly. (2021, Feburary 16). 【公屋重建】公屋的甘美:石硤尾大坑西邨. https://www.mpweekly.com/culture/石硤尾-大坑西邨-公屋-172569 

Yik, M. K. (2013, May 19). 大坑西新邨的沒落,也是私營廉租屋的沒落. Inmedia HK. https://www.inmediahk.net/規劃/大坑西新邨的沒落,也是私營廉租屋的沒落 

運房點線面. (2021, Oct 8). 【大坑西邨重建】. Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/THBHK/videos/1227763837719887/ 

1 thought on “[Field-Homework 3] Disappearing City

  1. Ran Ju says:

    As a mainland student not familiar with the traditional estate in Hong Kong, I learned a lot from your video. I like all the details you mentioned in the old corridor, which creates a special atmosphere there. And you really did wide and good research of the corridor and the old building. As you mentioned this place is full of the childhood memory of many people, I am curious about is what do people usually do in these corridors? Are there any daily interactions between neighbourhoods? Have these activities changed as time passing?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.