[READING RESPONSE] Ackbar Abbas

It is so inspiring that the writer divides global cities to two categaries which are invisible city and generic city. An invisible city reminds me of a japanese animation movie, directed by Miyazaki Hayao, called “Castle in the sky” which is so mapping to the definition of an invisible city that it don’t have an unambiguous image to the public. It’s kind of like a myth that nobody ever go up there, and can imagine what it have or looks like. It’s unreal compared to the generic city. An generic city is always transforming its features, and therefore easy to

Continue reading[READING RESPONSE] Ackbar Abbas

[READING RESPONSE] Ackbar Abbas

Abbas’ (2003) article offers a critique of globalization from the lenses of architecture and cinema. In this response, I’d like to humbly comment on his notion of the Generic City. The city that overperforms its “legibility” and “imageability”, in other words, that obsesses over architectural recognizability, ironically becomes the “Generic City”. Koolhaas argues that the Generic City has “overcome any fixation on identity”, implying that it is void of personality by choice. Looking back at my experiences of touring Shenzhen and Guangzhou – Tier 1 cities of China that embody the country’s modernization – it seems other than the varied

Continue reading[READING RESPONSE] Ackbar Abbas

[Reading Response: Sue Harris]

Architecture can symbolise power and status, this is magnified in films, especially in sci-fis where there are clear split in power and character. One of the obvious choice is Washington, where the Capitol Hill and White House is located. Being one of the most important place in the world, they represent and symbolise the dominant political power the government insert into the people and even the whole world. On the other hand, Moscow is often presented as the villain or the spies in Western blockbusters for example in James Bond. Different styles of architecture also present different impressions to the

Continue reading[Reading Response: Sue Harris]

[Reading response: Ackbar Abbas]

I would like to discuss further the issue of the generic city. As it is, I personally think it is a tool for filmmakers to use the emotional attachment and shock factor to empower their films without raising too many issues. This is more prominent in films where the story is dark and closer to life. For example, in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the Transformers serious, we see specific cities being used as the background of the film. These films are so obviously fictional and out of the ordinary that viewers are unlikely to associate said city with the

Continue reading[Reading response: Ackbar Abbas]

[Reading Response: Ackbar Abbas]

Ackbar Abbas mainly discusses two types of city, invisible city and generic city. An invisible city is a city without a clear image whereas the generic city is more like a city which keeps transforming and ‘erasing’ its history and identity. As mentioned, ‘many Generic cities today are located in Asia’, which is pretty true as far as I know. As an example, my hometown Jinan has been inhabited for more than 4000 years, many ancient buildings there actually represent periods of history. However, as time goes on, new buildings emerge and many ancient buildings have been demolished. To older

Continue reading[Reading Response: Ackbar Abbas]

Reading Response: Ackbar Abbas

As the writer said, “city allows itself to be evoked only through a certain kind of imagery”. Every city‘s impression is complicated and diverse, it could not be easily represented by a static picture. Therefore, the writer mentions that the instability of cinematic image could express the city. Meanwhile, many “anomalous details” in cinemas could lead to many turning points of audience understanding, which enable the city’s impression to become more stereoscopic and comprehensive. However, cinema may affect our understandings of a city. Due to “Cyber Kungfu”, the director could show images of the city that he wants to show,

Continue readingReading Response: Ackbar Abbas

[READING RESPONSE] ABBAS, M.A.

After reading this passage, it’s devastating to see how the characteristics of a generic city so accurately describe Hong Kong. The city is so desperate to define its identity after being defined by others for so long. The world might think that we won’t be able to sustain our economic power after our days as an entrepôt were over, that’s why we need to prove them wrong and continue to be Asia’s international city. Much of this urge to grow and develop economically makes our lives so vividly dull. The clone-like high rises and our everyday life that’s literally the

Continue reading[READING RESPONSE] ABBAS, M.A.

[READING RESPONSE] Ackbar Abbas

After reading the excerpt, I realize that the consequence of a city being generic is serious. A generic city is a city without identity and culture because different kinds of identity mix there. For example, we see Hong Kong as our home because of the sense of belonging and our identity of being Hongkonger. The city expands rapidly without proper city planning. Abbas mentioned that a large part of urban life is moved to cyberspace. With the advancement in technology, people can chat and have entertainment online. The bonding between people is weakened and the distances between people are lengthened.

Continue reading[READING RESPONSE] Ackbar Abbas

[Reading Response: Ackbar Abbas]

In the article, Ackbar Abbas poses arguments about the different changes that have been takin place in cities and how a strict analysis of cinema helps us understand these changes. The writer has mainly probed into two kinds of cities: Exorbitant and generic cities. He has defined exorbitant city as a city that is impossible to capture in one scene, it is not photogenic and cannot draw on the available repertoire of images, it relates to the kind of uncertain sociality found in cities where social relations are either changing or have broken down. On the other hand, he defines

Continue reading[Reading Response: Ackbar Abbas]

Reading Response: Sue Harris

The theme of “The Bourne Identity” is far beyond the simple opposition between good and evil in the action movies of the same period, and moves towards deeper thinking about the existence of society and individuals. Jason Byrne’s motivation in the entire trilogy is to retrieve memories and complete atonement, not to save the world and maintain justice as usual in Hollywood blockbusters in the 1990s. Because of this, the audience can find sympathy and empathy with Jason Bourne, who has lost his heroic aura. What we see is an ordinary person with scars, not a hero who is omnipotent

Continue readingReading Response: Sue Harris