Reading Response 1 Noirs: The City, the Woman and Other Spaces by Seng

The article explores the representation of urban interior spaces in Hong Kong films of the 1960s, particularly in the genres of melodrama and noir thriller. These films depicted the aspirations and struggles of both the working-class and high-society women, highlighting the increasing inequality brought about by city’s modernization. The female protagonists, embodied by the working-class woman and the high society lady vigilante, symbolize different aspects of Hong Kong’s identity during the Cold War era.

Depictions of interior spaces such as houses, apartments, factories and theaters play an important role in revealing the construction of cities and their social dynamics. The working-class woman’s place in the city is defined by her home, work space, and leisure space, while the upper-class vigilante moves effortlessly between modern interiors and darker, technologically advanced spaces . These contrasting images reflect the aspirations and challenges faced by women from different social classes. Let’s discuss the movies “Black Rose” and “Elevator Girl” as examples. In “Black Rose,” the sisters’ secret underground rooms and ornate living rooms contrast sharply with the dark back alleys where the city’s poor live. In Elevator Girl, the elevator serves as a workplace and introduces the audience to the urban aesthetics of the emerging middle class.

Overall, the article raises questions about the construction of an aspirational yet volatile Hong Kong identity through the mobilization of female protagonists and their respective interior spaces. It  mirrors the city’s transformation into a modern metropolis and reflected the urban realities and social inequalities faced by its residents.

2 thoughts on “Reading Response 1 Noirs: The City, the Woman and Other Spaces by Seng

  1. Dilruba says:

    You identified the key themes, such as the construction of cities, social inequalities, aspirations, struggles of women, and the impact of modernization depicted in Hong Kong cinema. Could you please elaborate on the struggle for high society women referring to the text and how it symbolizes Hong Kong that you have mentioned in your first paragraph?

    Reply
    1. Chung Hin says:

      The struggle of high society women in the films serves as a microcosm of the broader socio-economic disparities and power dynamics present in Hong Kong during the mid-1950s to mid-1960s. The depiction of these women navigating between their privileged lifestyles (hosting evening soirees in their villas) and hidden activities in the city like Black Roses mirrors the complexities of the city’s identity and its entanglement in Sino-British disputes. Just as the high society women oscillate between their public and private personas, Hong Kong grapples with its own identity and geopolitical challenges.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.