Hong Kong as a City of Disappearance

In Abbas’ Hong Kong: Culture and Politics of Disappearance (1997), Hong Kong is presented as a city of disappearance, where there exists a gap, or hysteresis, between the city and its representation through media and architecture. Hong Kong exists in a limbo between its identity as a British colony and a Chinese city, and an overarching sense of nostalgia colours our image into one of a fleeting, unstable nature. Abbas contends that our image of the city is one that views Hong Kong from a distant and impersonal lens; architecture and iconic landmarks are used as easily recogniseable symbols to represent

Continue readingHong Kong as a City of Disappearance

Field Trip 2: Tram

Tilt Shift and Time Lapse   While on the tram, the scene I could catch out was the miniature-like view of Hong Kong. Compare to the size that I actually observe, size on the screen was way more smaller than it was. So I tried to demonstrate the tilt shift method by using some time lapse in horizontal, vertical, and diagonal angles. “Children of the Millennial” Co-existence of old and new generation of Hong Kong was the subject matter that I tried to merge in two different video clips. This distinct contrast paradoxically explains continuous legacy from the past to

Continue readingField Trip 2: Tram

Fill that Void – Let Architecture Times

“We become aware of void as we fill it (Porchia, 1943).” No matter are we glimpsing at, passing through or sheltered by architecture, it is often regarded as nothing as compared to the complexity of life we are housed. However, by breaking the general sensory provoking approach, Andy Warhol presented the 8 hours-movie: Empire (1964) to film stationary skyscraper with the juxtaposition of variance brought by time. As the building takes the lead throughout the movie, it brings touchable urban movement and subtle climate changes to the front. Though qualification of Empire as a movie was in question, it is

Continue readingFill that Void – Let Architecture Times

Ghost in the Shell: Hong Kong’s Identity Crisis

In his essay ‘Building on Disappearance’, Akbar Abbas explored the disappearance of the city and the current self-definition dilemma. This dilemma is played out in space: while the Empire faded, centuries of influence and subjugation persist in the very streets of this multicultural ‘future’ city dominated by intersections of old and new, or more cliché East and the West. He contended that new challenges are present in Hong Kong’s extensive search for identity amid the rubble of British colonialism and the ongoing political integration with China. In his eyes, the irony lies where the very people of Hong Kong avoid

Continue readingGhost in the Shell: Hong Kong’s Identity Crisis

Hong Kong as a boring city

“Building on disappearance Hong Kong architecture and colonial space” is mainly about the issue of the identity of Hong Kong as a city being disappeared and the writer argues the issue through economic, cultural and political aspects. The highly dense population and the housing problem makes all the building type should only be functional so, consequently, all the buildings are drab and tall. It has become the main reason for killing the potential of designing various building styles and the other characteristics of the city have been disappeared. It shows “market erodes place” that the building type is controlled from the

Continue readingHong Kong as a boring city

Preservation of Hong Kong’s Identity

When people talk about a place, what comes up to mind at that instant is always a certain piece of architecture or the so-called landmark of a place. But Abbas brought up the critique of architecture being barely a piece of visual evidence does not take a role in representing a city’s identity (Abbas, Building on Disappearance, p.64). Which this leads to the discussion of what can represent the city or specifically, what can represent Hong Kong? Architecture as an object changes through time, due to the accentuation of the economy, old types of buildings cannot reach the standard of

Continue readingPreservation of Hong Kong’s Identity

The Remains and Disappearance: The Selectiveness of Architecture Preservation in Hong Kong under the Post-Colonial Context

Do the preserved old buildings represent the cultural memory of a city? Is it totally accidental that so many examples of preservation of architecture give people a sense of nostalgia? The essay Building on Disappearance: Hong Kong Architecture and Colonial Space written by Ackar Abbas (1997) argues that architecture preservation is not equal to the memory of Hong Kong, but the painless déjà vu after selection. The argument can be proved through the study of the Merely Local constructions, which indicates the buildings belong to a specific historical period and have been preserved until now. They have deeply rooted in Hong Kong’s

Continue readingThe Remains and Disappearance: The Selectiveness of Architecture Preservation in Hong Kong under the Post-Colonial Context

Preservation Through the Combination of Film, History, and Architecture

Building on Disappearance In his essay “Hong Kong: Culture and the politics of disappearance”, Ackbar Abbas examines the disappearance of colonial buildings and colonial history. The writer highlights the importance of the preservation process by depicting the importance of architecture as visual evidence of the city’s identity. He then links to three examples of preservation cases, which are misled, in Hong Kong to emphasize how true values of colonial identity have crumbled down. One notable example is the Repulse Bay hotel. First built in 1920 and remodeled in early 1982, the Repulse Bay has transformed from grand colonial style building

Continue readingPreservation Through the Combination of Film, History, and Architecture

Preservation in Hong Kong

In his writing, ‘Building on Disappearance,’ Abba describes the colonial space and disappearance of history. Among those variable topics in his reading, he explains why preservation of old buildings are important. Abba states that “preservation of old buildings gives us history in site, but it also means keeping history in sight.” (Abba, Building on Disappearance, p. 66). As Abba mentioned, preservation of old buildings are critical since it represents the history of one’s country. However, the word ‘preservation’ does not fit well to Hong Kong. Compared to other countries like South Korea or Japan, Hong Kong does not contain many

Continue readingPreservation in Hong Kong

The value of preservation

What is Hong Kong? This question to myself stayed in my head for the whole afternoon after I finished the reading ‘Building on Disappearance’ written by Ackar Abbas. In this reading the author investigated into the phenomenon of Hong Kong this city’s disappearance. The author challenges the idea of preservation, claiming that the act of preserving architecture is exactly what causes the disappearance of the city itself. Abbas claimed that the historic values didn’t survive through the preservation process. Either the architecture became a decoration to new buildings like the case of the clock tower in Tsim Sha Tsui, or

Continue readingThe value of preservation